Suggestions
Explore the featured selections!
House Salad
Blood Orange
Donnoli
Black & White Cookie
About
Arthur Avenue
Welcome to Arthur Avenue, a culinary gem nestled in the heart of Pleasantville, NY. Located at 210 Marble Ave, this charming eatery has quickly become a local favorite for its authentic Italian fare, particularly its renowned wood-fired pizzas. With a commitment to quality and freshness, Arthur Avenue is a must-visit for anyone craving delicious comfort food that feels like a warm hug.
As you step inside, the inviting atmosphere welcomes you, and the delightful aroma of freshly baked pizzas fills the air. The menu boasts an array of delectable options, from classic sandwiches like the Chicken Parm ($15.00) and now-famous The Godfather sandwich—a delightful fusion of grilled chicken, mozzarella, cherry peppers, and prosciutto on garlic bread ($16.00)—to their mouthwatering Borgatti's Cheese Raviolis topped with rich tomato sauce ($15.95).
Arthur Avenue is not just about pizza, though; their catering menu features a variety of crowd-pleasers such as the Baked Ziti Tray and Eggplant Parmigiana Tray, ensuring that no matter the occasion, you'll be serving up authentic Italian delight. Whether you’re hosting a family gathering or a casual get-together, Arthur Avenue provides comfort in every bite.
The rave reviews speak volumes about their dedication to quality. Customers like Tricia hail the perfect crust and balanced toppings, while SPD emphasizes the welcoming service and top-notch atmosphere. It's clear that every plate is crafted with care, making it easy to see why regulars often indulge in an impromptu pizza feast on the way home. As Mike A noted, the anticipation of biting into fresh pizza right out of the oven is an experience every visitor should look forward to.
As a food reviewer at Foodjoyy, I can confidently say that my experience at Arthur Avenue was nothing short of exceptional. With each bite, you can taste the passion that fuels this kitchen, and my own favorites include the sausage and broccoli rabe pizza, with its tender cheese and garlic-rich flavor that dances on the palate. This establishment is a testament to the art of Italian cuisine, marrying tradition with freshness and quality in a way that leaves you eager for more.
So, if you ever find yourself in Pleasantville, do not hesitate. Make your way to Arthur Avenue; it’s an experience that delights the senses and warms the soul—one slice at a time.
Book a table
Make A Reservation
“ We’re from Albany but were in the area visiting my sister in Westchester Med. I was craving good pizza so decided to look for a place not too far from the hospital. A Google search brought us here and wow am I thankful! This was one of the best pizzas I’ve had. The crust was perfect. Just the right amount of sauce and cheese. Fresh basil. The service was great and the pizzas are made fresh to order. We will most definitely be stopping by again! ”
“ Great pizza! I just ordered delivery. Looking forward to going there in person and chomping one fresh out of the oven! ”
“ If you are looking for authentic wood fire pizza, Arthur Ave is the spot! I had the pleasure of having lunch here with my CertaPro Painters team and it was one of best pizza’s I had lately. Out of the 4 pies we ordered, my favorite had to be the eggplant. Crust was baked perfectly and just the right amount of eggplant. The owners were very welcoming. Top notch service, pizza and atmosphere, you can’t go wrong. Don’t walk, run to if you are looking for delicious pizza. ”
“ I am addicted to their pizza. It’s a cute place with extremely friendly staff. I have had their pizza, meatballs & meatball spring rolls... Their food is outstanding, I can’t wait to try more. If you are looking for an Italian place for a quick bite within 10 minutes of Pleasantville this should be the only place you’re going. Cannot recommend enough ”
“ Been getting takeout from here for years and it's fantastic everytime. I always get the sausage and broccoli rabe pizza and it's probably my favorite pizza I've ever had. The crust is amazing, the sausage is delicious and plentiful and I love the broccoli rabe, tender and big chunks of garlic. Both pictures are from my car because I usually eat half (or all) of the pizza before I leave the parking lot and then get a chicken parm wedge to take home to eat later. ”
“ The Bee Sting pizza was superb. It's the closest pizza I've had outside of Rome (the rest of Italy included) that tasted like a Roman-style pizza, super thin, with minimal fire-crisped crust. Juicy. Good sauce. The cooks were polite and personal, but give you space. The pizzeria is cozy and clean. Great Italian-American ambience with Sinatra playing in the background. I look forward to returning. ”
“ Another box to check on the CertaPro Painters of Westchester NY Pizza Challenge! This is not your average pizza spot, so don’t come in here expecting a reheated slice that’s been sitting there all day. Instead, fresh personal sized pizzas are made quickly to order! They have a variety of specialty pies as well as daily specials. My favorite so far is the Bee Sting, although I’ll be back soon enough to try them all! ”
“ I love Pizza. I love New York pizza.. I LOVE THIS NEW YORK PIZZA. It’s amazing :) go enjoy please and thanks. Highly recommend the Margherita and this one on the photo was their day special: sun dried tomatoes, pesto, basil. Incredible. ”